• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies – Best Philly Cheese Steaks and Quality Pizza in Butler, PA

Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies in Butler, PA, shines with authentic, flavorful Philly cheesesteaks and generously topped pizzas crafted from quality meats and cheeses. Customers praise the juicy, perfectly cooked steaks and fresh, vibrant ingredients that bring each bite to life. Whether you crave a classic pizza or a hearty hoagie, Diamond Joes delivers superb taste and excellent value. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make dining in or ordering delivery a pleasure. This spot truly stands out for its commitment to quality and flavor, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors seeking genuine, satisfying American comfort food.

Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies at a glance

  • Address 1640 N Main St Ext, Butler, PA 16001, United States
  • Phone +1 724-286-7727
  • Restaurant type Restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies: Reviews & Ratings

Arthur VanScoy
5

Everyone was great to be around. My pizza was made to professional high quality. They give ample toppings for the money your spend. I would highly recommend them. They also use top quality meats and cheeses. Grande Cheese top notch.

Mary Ann Ramage
5

We ordered a pizza and cheesesteak hoagie for delivery. It was our first time ordering from here and we were not disappointed. Both were outstanding and we would definitely recommend Diamond Joes to anyone. Butler needs a place like this.

Casey Love
5

I ordered a small Philly cheese steak over the weekend and than 2 large ones today if that says anything to begin with lol I have to say it is one of the Best Philly Cheese Steaks I've had in a LONG time! The meat had so much flavor and just such a juicy mouthful. everything was cooked to perfection! Everywhere I went around here to get a cheese steak it was always so bland and over priced and dry. I've been telling all my friends and family where they can get an AUTHENTIC Philly cheese steak from and will be ordering again!

mary mary
4

First time ordering…Cheese Steak salad was awesome and fresh. Lots of steak, cheese, fresh veggies. BUT…..$7.00 for 7 small fried mushrooms Family liked the chicken hoagies. Would order again but not the mushrooms.

Wendy Saeler
5

Wow.... All I can say is this place has it going on!! Stopped in today, pizza was amazing. I would highly recommend for carry out or delivery. You are able to dine in, though. We will be back.

Avalon 9799
5

The first time in we ordered pizza and Philly cheesesteak hoagies. They were hands down one of the the best we've ever had, and my son who is extremely picky about cheesesteak loved it. The pizza is spectacular! If you love fresh crust you won't be disappointed! Second time we once again ordered the cheesesteak. Fresh, flavorful buns and the best tasting tender steak around. We also got a stromboli to try and it was amazing! The crust was exceptional and the filling was delicious! Do yourself a favor and try out this gem of a restaurant! We'll definitely be back!

Location

  • Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies
    Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies
    1640 N Main St Ext, Butler, PA 16001, United States Hotline: +1 724-286-7727

Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies, located at 1640 N Main St Ext in Butler, PA, stands out as a local gem for anyone craving authentic, hearty Italian-American fare. From the moment you step inside or place an order, you sense a commitment to quality that’s rare in today’s fast-food scene. Customers consistently praise the generous toppings on their pizzas, which are crafted with top-tier meats and cheeses—qualities that elevate each bite beyond ordinary expectations.

The hoagies here, especially the Philly cheese steak, earn high marks for their rich, juicy flavor and perfectly cooked ingredients. It's clear that Diamond Joes doesn't cut corners; the meat is flavorful and tender, giving true depth to classic sandwiches without skimping on freshness or authenticity. The cheesesteak hoagies resonate as a true highlight, delivering a mouthwatering experience that local diners crave and recommend.

Moreover, the menu’s variety extends to fresh salads and more traditional pizza options, making it a versatile spot whether you're dining in, carrying out, or ordering delivery. Customer feedback highlights the attentive service and inviting atmosphere, reinforcing Diamond Joes as a reliable choice for comfort food made right. While some sides like the fried mushrooms may raise an eyebrow, the core offerings more than justify a visit.

In essence, Diamond Joes Pizza & Hoagies combines quality ingredients, generous portions, and authentic flavors in a way that feels both nostalgic and satisfying. For anyone in Butler seeking top-notch pizza and hoagies that honor tradition while delivering on taste, this restaurant is a standout destination well worth exploring.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards